Professional Update
A
monthly newsletter for KZN Attorneys from the Kwazulu-Natal Law Society

12 June 2009

This professional service draws attention to current and important items of news
 and members are directed to the hosts' websites

InfoUpdate 12 of 2009
Useful Links
and Items of Interest  
 

United States, Canada and South America

Banking

Bank regulation blowout - 17 June
The Obama administration seems to have found a way to fill the regulatory gaps in the banking system : call for regulation of just about everything in sight and hope that most of it becomes law. Wednesday at noon, the president will outline his plan, which he wants Congress to write into law by the year's end. The administration proposes changes in five key areas. - Forbes website

Regulation in the financial sector, and Obama's "Financial Regulatory Reform" - 19 June
Interview with Robert Foster (Alternative Management Association), Russell Loubser (JSE) and Felicity Duncan on the Moneyweb website

Brazil

Brazil's Lula signs Amazon bill - 26 June
Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has approved a controversial bill allowing Amazon farmers to acquire an area of public land larger than France. But the president vetoed some of the most contentious clauses that would have enabled absentee landlords and companies to benefit from the measure. Smaller parcels of public land will be handed over for free, and larger ones at reduced or market rates. Critics say it will amount to an amnesty for illegal land-grabbers. - BBC News website

Canada

South African judge criticises HIV criminalisation in Canada - 13 June
Canada is the world leader in criminalising people with HIV, according to Justice Edwin Cameron of the South African Constitutional Court. Cameron, the first senior official in South Africa to publicly disclose his HIV-positive status, was in Toronto Friday evening to address lawyers and policy-makers at the Law Society of Upper Canada.  He spoke out against the growing trend in Canada of criminally prosecuting people who fail to disclose their HIV status. Earlier this year, a court in Hamilton, Ontario became the first in the world to convict a man of murder for failing to disclose his HIV-positive status to his sexual partners, two of whom later died of AIDS.  Since then, criminal prosecutions have increased and the degree of charges being laid has been elevated. - Rabble website

Weird cases : possession of pie with unlawful intent - 26 June
The Supreme Court of Canada will soon hear a case about an arrest for "possession of a pie with unlawful intent". Surreally, the pie didn't even exist but the case has now become one of major constitutional importance in Canada. The story started in 2002 when police said they believed that someone in Vancouver was going to throw a pie at Jean Chrétien, the Canadian Prime Minister. A judge later described the evidence for the plot as nothing more than "a third hand rumour". Nonetheless, the police swung into action. Cameron Ward, a prominent lawyer often involved in litigating cases of alleged police misconduct, was arrested and subsequently sued the police, the city and the provincial government for wrongful arrest, false imprisonment and negligence. He offered to settle the case in return for an apology but his offer was rejected. Ward won the case although the judgment swung on violations of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, not on specifically illegal police conduct.   The Supreme Court of Canada will now consider in what circumstances damages should be awarded to a citizen whose constitutional rights have been infringed but where the authorities haven't broken any particular law. - Times Online website

Constitutional Law

Supreme Court avoids major voting rights ruling - 22 June
The US Supreme Court declined on Monday to rule on the constitutionality of part of the landmark 1965 Voting Rights Act which sought to protect minorities in states with a history of racial discrimination. The nation's top court instead ruled on a more narrow constitutional question, deciding that political subdivisions within a state can apply to be exempted from the Act. - Reuters website

Justices retain oversight by US on voting - 22 June
The Supreme Court on Monday left intact one of the signature legacies of the civil rights movement, the Voting Rights Act of 1965. - New York Times website

Justices exempt Texas district from Voting Rights Act - 22 June
The Voting Rights Act, the government's chief weapon against racial discrimination at polling places since the 1960s, survived a Supreme Court challenge Monday in a ruling that nevertheless warned of serious constitutional questions posed by part of the law. Major civil rights groups and other defenders of the landmark law breathed a sigh of relief when the court ruled narrowly in favor of a small Texas governing authority while sidestepping the larger constitutional issue. - New York Times website
Keyphrase :
Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District v Holder

Courts

Supreme Court rejects school strip search - 25 June
A public school violated the privacy rights of a teenage girl who had to disrobe on suspicion she had ibuprofen pills, the US Supreme Court ruled on Thursday in its first decision on student strip searches. The ruling by the nation's high court was a major defeat for school officials who had defended the strip search as necessary for student safety, school order and combating a growing drug problem. School officials in Safford, Arizona, had ordered the strip search in 2003 of the 13 year-old in the eighth grade. It did not turn up any ibuprofen - an over-the-counter anti-inflammatory medication used to treat fever, headaches and pain - or any other drugs. The strip search was prompted by an unverified tip from a girl. In another part of the ruling, Souter said the school officials who ordered or carried out the search were entitled to immunity from liability because of uncertainty over whether the right had been clearly established at that time. - Reuters website

Lawyer Edward Fagan is disbarred in NJ for misusing Holocaust victims' funds - 24 June
Only a few years ago, Edward Fagan was a world-renowned lawyer for the underdog, brash and audacious enough to take on Swiss banks and even whole countries to win judgments for Holocaust survivors and victims of South African apartheid. This week, the Supreme Court announced he was barred from practicing law in New Jersey, completing one of the steepest falls from grace in the state's law community. The court found Fagan, 56, misappropriated nearly $400 000 of the money he won for the victims he so effectively championed. - NJ.com website

See also :
Apartheid suit faces hurdles, reparations row - 18 June
A multi-billion dollar suit against Swiss and US banks on behalf of victims of apartheid faces daunting legal hurdles and has fuelled debate over who should pay for the sins of white-ruled South Africa. More than 500 South Africans called a telephone hotline on its first day to join a $50 billion class action suit to be filed soon in a New York court by Edward Fagan, a US lawyer known for his controversial tactics. - SABC News website
[InfoUpdate 16 of 2002]

Lawyers proving the 'slippery slope' is real - 7 June
If you've spent any time at all on Internet message boards or in college debate class you'll have seen the rafters vibrate with righteous condemnation against the "slippery slope argument". It is claimed that a worst case, ultimate extrapolation of a thing is a bad argument because it isn't necessarily a truism. A case brought against South Africa by class-action attorneys many years after apartheid ended is a "dramatic example," say Bradley and Goldsmith. It was brought to a New York court in hopes of penalizing American corporations for having had dealings with South Africa during the years of apartheid. The Bush administration opposed the litigation. Even the post-apartheid South African government opposed the litigation because they felt it interfered with its own policies. Even the Supreme Court ruled that the executive branch had privilege in dealing with South Africa. But the arrogant New York court didn't care. Unfortunately, the activists in the New York court refused to dismiss the case despite so many voices opposed to it. What is the result? This case can now go forward to interfere with the right of South Africa to reconcile with its own past in its own ways and could have major economic impact on our own economy by ruling that American firms are now liable for what some other country did with its people. - Right Side News website
Keyphrase :
United States. 'Apartheid Case'

Rights case gone wrong - 18 April
As American taxpayers shell out hundreds of billions of dollars to bail out US companies, a federal court in New York recently paved the way for significantly increasing some of these firms' financial burdens. Relying on the Alien Tort Statute of 1789, the court ruled this month that certain companies that did business with apartheid South Africa - including distressed firms such as General Motors and Ford - can be held liable for South Africa's human rights violations during that period. The underlying acts associated with apartheid are abhorrent. But it is crass retroactivity to say that these firms are legally responsible for actions of the South African government. Under the New York court's standard, a great deal of global investment in the developing world would now be subject to US judicial scrutiny. - The Washington Post website

Counties get sympathy but no money from judges on juvenile legal costs - 6 June
Faced with tens of thousands of dollars in added expenses caused by the need to pay additional attorneys to help low-income parents in juvenile court cases, county commissioners received sympathy but not many dollars Friday from the judges of the 25th Judicial Circuit. Meeting in what's called an "en banc" session, the judges told Pulaski County Presiding Commissioner Bill Ransdall and others that they ought to lobby the state legislature, not the judges, to solve the problem. Phelps County Associate Circuit Judge Ralph Haslag and other judges said the risk of a person not having a legal advocate and then appealing is too great and the judges have to follow procedures to ensure adequate legal representation for poor parents. - Pulaski County Daily website

Cyberlaw

US mum is guilty of file-sharing - 19 June
A woman has been ordered to pay $1.9 million (£1.2m) in the only file-sharing case to go to trial in the US. A jury in Minnesota ruled Jammie Thomas-Rasset, 32, had violated music copyright and must pay damages to the record industry. The mother of four from Minnesota was accused of illegally sharing 24 songs from artists including Sheryl Crow and Green Day. - BBC News website

Entertainment

Promoter sues Michael Jackson - 10 June
A New Jersey concert promoter, AllGood Entertainment, has sued the singer for breach of contract and fraud. Jackson is accused of backing out of an agreement to perform in a Jackson Family Reunion concert to sign with concert giant AEG Live to perform 50 concerts at London's O2 Arena. The suit seeks at least $20 million in damages and to bar Jackson's London appearances, set to begin next month. - Los Angeles Times website

Deep pockets behind Michael Jackson - 1 June
In this, the first part of an absorbing story on the come backing "King of Pop", Michael Jackson finds an unlikely champion in a financier who made his fortune investing in distressed assets. - Business Mirror website

More woes for Michael Jackson - 14 June
In recent years, it has seemed that all of Jackson's time and energy has been spent on litigation rather than music. Certainly, it's been the source of the bulk of the conversation and publicity surrounding the tabloid beloved star. - gaywired website

Michael Jackson dead at 50 - 25 June
ABC website

O2 arena counts cost as curtain closes on the greatest show of all - 26 June
AEG Live, the company that persuaded Michael Jackson to sign up for 50 nights at the O2 arena, is facing a liability of up to £300 million and a dark house for the next nine months. - Times Online website

Michael Jackson leaves hefty debts - 26 June
The Times website

A look at the career of Michael Jackson - 26 June
Associated Press on Google website

Environment

Court orders $507.5 million damages in Exxon Valdez spill - 15 June
A federal appeals court on Monday ordered Exxon Mobil Corp to pay $507.5 million in punitive damages stemming from the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill off Alaska, plus 5.9 percent interest running from the 1996 trial judgment, the opinion said. The amount is a fraction of the $5 billion in punitive damages originally awarded to fishermen, Alaska natives, business owners and other litigants by a jury in 1996, and equals the compensatory damages agreed to in a subsequent settlement, the opinion said. The opinion issued on Monday by the Ninth US Circuit Court of Appeals set the punitive damages figure, and determined the date from which the interest would run, after the US Supreme Court ruled that the maximum ratio of punitive to compensatory damages is 1:1 under maritime law. - Reuters website

Finance

Madoff victims push 150-year sentence - 16 June
More than 100 victims of failed financier Bernard L. Madoff’s multibillion-dollar fraud have urged a judge to sentence him harshly, saying he ruined their lives, leaving many of them depressed, bitter and hopeless. Letter after letter urged US District Judge Denny Chin to sentence Madoff to the maximum 150 years in prison after he pleaded guilty in March to securities fraud, perjury and other charges. Madoff, who has been jailed since he entered his guilty plea, is scheduled to be sentenced on June 29. - Jakarta Globe website

4 people and firm sued in Madoff case - 22 June
Three lawsuits filed on Monday provided new details about what regulators say went on inside Bernard L Madoff's long-running Ponzi scheme, including information about who might have helped perpetuate the fraud for so long. No one but Mr Madoff and his accountant have faced criminal charges so far. But in two civil fraud cases filed Monday, federal regulators contend that a prominent investor and a small brokerage firm both helped Mr Madoff sustain the Ponzi scheme by steering billions of dollars into it, in exchange for hundreds of millions of dollars in fees and profits. - New York Times website

Madoff asks for 12 years in jail - 24 June
Disgraced US financier Bernard Madoff's lawyer has said his client deserves 12 years in prison for his crimes. In March, Madoff pleaded guilty to 11 charges that he masterminded a $50bn (£35bn) investment fraud. He will be sentenced on 29 June and could be jailed for up to 150 years. Madoff is 71 years old now. - BBC News website

Foreign Policy

4 June 2009
Obama : Address by the US President at Cairo University
Polity website

Muslims not sure President Obama's speech means real change - 5 June
President Obama's much-anticipated speech Thursday to the Muslim world sought to dissolve the mistrust between Islam and the West by highlighting his personal appeal as he called for an end to intolerance and violence and a move toward a shared future. It was a carefully textured blend of history, the president's experience with Islam and the need to quell religious extremism. The 55-minute address at Cairo University was short on policy details. Many in this region want deeds and progress and believe that the speech was more of a balancing act than an aggressive agenda. - Los Angeles Times website

Health

Obama signs landmark law to regulate tobacco - 22 June
President Barack Obama, citing his own struggle to give up smoking, signed a law on Monday giving the US government broad regulatory power for the first time over cigarettes and other tobacco products. Obama said the law would curb the ability of tobacco companies to market their products to the young. The law followed a campaign by tobacco industry foes in Congress for more than a decade to put cigarettes under the control of the US Food and Drug Administration. It allows the FDA to put strict limits on the manufacturing and marketing of tobacco products but stops short of allowing it to ban cigarettes or their addictive ingredient nicotine. - Reuters website

Human Rights

Supreme Court to decide federal sex offender law - 22 June
The US Supreme Court said on Monday that it would decide whether Congress may adopt a federal law that keeps sex offenders in custody indefinitely after they complete their prison sentences. The high court agreed to hear an Obama administration appeal seeking to reinstate a 2006 law providing for the continued detention of "sexually dangerous" convicted federal inmates who have served their prison terms. A US appeals court based in Virginia struck down the law for exceeding the limits of congressional authority and intruding on police powers Constitution reserves for the states, many of which have similar laws. - Reuters website

Miami's tent city for sex offender - 21 June
A Miami law is forcing many of the city's sex offenders to sleep rough under a bridge, reports Emilio San Pedro for the BBC's Americana programme. The area under the Julia Tuttle Causeway in downtown Miami has in recent years become the unlikely home for a growing community of about 70 convicted sex offenders. They have ended up living in a makeshift tent city under one of the causeway's bridges because of a local law which prohibits those who have sexually abused minors from living within 2 500 ft (760m) of anywhere where children congregate, such as schools, libraries and parks. - BBC News website

Labour Issues

Tentative settlement at The Boston Globe - 24 June
After months of bitter struggle that included a threat to shut down The Boston Globe, the New York Times Company and the paper's largest union reached a tentative contract settlement on Tuesday night, with employees agreeing to significant cuts in wages, benefits and job security. - New York Times website

Land Affairs

Atlanta is making way for new public housing - 20 June
In 1936, Atlanta built Techwood Homes, the nation's first housing project. By the 1990s, a greater percentage of the city's residents were living in housing projects - sprawling red-brick barracks that pockmarked the skyline - than in any other city in America. Now, Atlanta is nearing a very different record : becoming the first major city to knock them all down. By next June, officials here plan to demolish the city's last remaining housing project, fulfilling a long and divisive campaign to reduce poverty by decentralizing it.  - New York Times website

Mexico

'No extradition' for kidnap woman - 23 June
Mexican President Felipe Calderon has said a French woman who was convicted of kidnapping will have to serve her 60-year sentence in Mexico. The French government had been urging the Mexican authorities to extradite Florence Cassez, who has long pleaded her innocence. But Mr Calderon said Mexican law must be upheld. - BBC News website

Miscellaneous

Chronic Lyme disease treatment could face insurance battle - 14 June
Many Lyme disease patients rejoiced last month when the General Assembly unanimously passed a bill specifying that physicians could diagnose the controversial chronic Lyme disease and prescribe equally contentious long-term antibiotics to treat the tick-borne illness without fear of reprisal. But the bill, which needs to be signed by Republican Gov. M. Jodi Rell, did not address another issue: Must insurance companies cover the extended treatments when various health organizations do not recognize the existence of chronic Lyme and warn against overuse of antibiotics? - The Advocate website

Announcing James Kilgore's We are All Zimbabweans Now (with Excerpt) - 3 June
Umuzi proudly announces the release of We Are All Zimbabweans Now by James Kilgore. Written from a California prison cell by this one-time fugitive author, the book occupies an important place amongst the fictional chronicles of post-independence Zimbabwe. - Umuzi website

See also :
Symbionese Liberation Army member released on parole - 10 May 2009
Los Angeles Times website

InfoUpdate : an Information Service supplied by the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society