Professional Update
A
monthly newsletter for KZN Attorneys from the Kwazulu-Natal Law Society

1 June 2009

This professional service draws attention to current and important items of news
 and members are directed to the hosts' websites

 

InfoUpdate 11 of 2009
Useful Links
and Items of Interest 
 

 
United Kingdom

Company Law

Fraud tempts more directors of insolvent companies - 4 May
The number of directors of insolvent companies disqualified for financial crime is soaring as the recession takes hold, according to government figures. Research released by Wedlake Bell, the law firm, based on figures from the Insolvency Service, shows a 72 per cent increase in the year to the end of March in director disqualification at insolvent companies where directors have been implicated in fraud and other financial crime. The directors of 91 companies were banned for financial crime over the year as more directors turned to fraud to try to salvage something for themselves from ailing companies. -
Times Online website

See also : Employers warned of likely rise in staff fraud

Courts

Do not widen out-of-court penalties, magistrates tell Jack Straw - 5 May
Magistrates want ministers to halt the widening of on-the-spot fines for offenders, warning that serious crimes are not reaching the courts. They have told Jack Straw, the Justice Secretary, that the use of the fines in cases involving assault is undermining confidence in the justice system. Defence solicitors say that serious offences are being dealt with inappropriately, or not at all, for lack of police time and resources. A dossier collated by Edward Garnier, QC, the Conservative justice spokesman, indicates lawyers' concerns that their clients are being "let off" over alleged assaults and even rape rather than prosecuted. -
Times Online website

Ex-City lawyer wins right to sue for £5m over Catholic school abuse - 6 May
The Roman Catholic Church in Britain could face a surge of US-style compensation claims over child abuse after a former City lawyer yesterday won the right to claim £5 million in damages. Patrick Raggett, 50, claims that his life was ruined because of years of insidious abuse by Father Michael Spencer, a teacher at the Jesuit-run Preston Catholic College in Lancashire. Child abuse has cost the Roman Catholic Church in the US more than $2.6 billion, with $436 million paid out last year alone. -
Times Online website

Bid to transfer Lockerbie bomber - 6 May
The Libyan authorities have requested that the man convicted of the Lockerbie bombing be transferred from Scotland. The application for the transfer of Abdelbaset Ali al-Megrahi was received by the Scottish Government. The move came after a prisoner transfer agreement was ratified by the UK and Libyan governments last week. -
BBC News website

Would-be wine buff leaves bad taste - 3 May
Pursuing a dream to become a winemaker in South Africa has yielded more than just sour grapes for a British businessman who now faces fraud charges. Tony Hindhaugh quit his pub chain management job in England in 2005 and settled in Stellenbosch where he was filmed in a 10-part documentary, The Grape Escape, while learning to run a wine estate in a series screened on the Discovery Channel. But after the TV cameras stopped rolling, Eaglevlei's investors - who had reportedly ploughed £1-million into the project - raised concerns over how the business was being run. Hindhaugh left the wine estate under a cloud in 2007. On Wednesday, the 39-year-old will appear in the Newcastle Magistrate's Court in the UK on charges of fraud and forgery. It is unclear if his arrest is linked to his departure from the South African wine farm. -
The Times website

Criminal Justice System

Public given greater say as new crime strategy is published - 12 May
Local people will be able to choose how money from a £4 million criminal assets fund is spent in their area, alongside further targeted work to tackle property-related crime and a tougher approach to dealing with prolific offenders. Speaking today at the first conference for Crime and Disorder Reduction Partnerships (CDRPs), the Prime Minister unveiled the Government's updated crime strategy - Cutting Crime : Two Years On - and set out the Government's commitment to tackling the new crime challenges the country faces. The action the Government is taking will build on existing policies to prevent crime and deliver responsive, visible justice which has resulted in a fall in crime of almost 40 per cent since 1997. -
eGov Monitor website

Environment

'Dirty tricks' over toxic waste - 13 May
London's High Court will on Wednesday hear allegations of dirty tricks in the biggest class action ever brought before the British courts. It arises from the dumping of toxic waste three years ago in Ivory Coast's largest city, Abidjan. In the aftermath, up to 100 000 people fell sick and 16 died. The waste belonged to a multi-national oil trading company, Trafigura. In the wake of the incident, 30 000 Abidjanis are suing them for damages. The law firm representing the Abidjanis, Leigh Day and Co, allege a dirty tricks operation by Trafigura agents in Abidjan. In March this year, pending a full hearing of those allegations, the High Court issued an injunction forbidding Trafigura representatives - including leading London law firm Macfarlanes - from contacting the claimants. -
BBC News website

Dirty tricks and toxic waste in Ivory Coast - 13 May
It is the biggest toxic dumping scandal of the 21st century, the type of environmental vandalism that international treaties are supposed to prevent. Now Newsnight can reveal the truth about the waste that was illegally tipped on Ivory Coast's biggest city, Abidjan. - Newsnight on the
BBC News website

European Court of Justice

News release from Webber Wentzel

European Court of Justice rules in favour of South African trade mark

13 May 2009

The European Court of Justice ("ECJ") has delivered a much awaited decision relating to a dispute between Ireland's glassware giant, Waterford Wedgwood Plc, and a Stellenbosch based South African company Assembled Investments (Pty) Ltd (which owns the trade marks used by Waterford Wines (Pty) Ltd).

Leanne Mostert, a partner in the Cape Town office of Webber Wentzel, who represented Assembled Investments, commented, "On 7 May, after an almost decade long battle, the ECJ found in favour of Assembled Investments. Not only is this a great victory for South Africa, and for a South African brand but the decision also sets a global precedent. We are clearly pleased with ECJ's decision and the positive impact it will have on our client's business".

"The ECJ's decision finally puts to bed a long disputed issue. It establishes that even where a proposed trade mark is identical or similar to an earlier mark with a particularly high distinctive character, there must still be some degree of similarity between the respective goods to establish a likelihood of confusion. Only then will the owner of an earlier mark be able to prevent the registration of a proposed similar mark on the basis of Article 8(1)(b) of the EU community trade mark regulations".

The dispute between the two companies first arose following the application by Assembled Investments to register a trade mark containing the words "Waterford Stellenbosch" for its wines in Europe.

Waterford Wedgwood argued that Assembled Investments' mark would lead to confusion in the marketplace and opposed the trade mark application on the basis of its own community trade mark "Waterford" registered earlier in connection with, among other products, glassware including wine glasses.

Mostert says the decision also confirms the 2007 decision of the EU's Court of First Instance that wine and wine glasses are not similar products despite a certain degree of complementarily between them.

Waterford Wines has been producing award winning wines at the Waterford Wine Estate in the Stellenbosch district, near Cape Town, South Africa since 1998. Jeremy Ord, a founder of Didata is one of the owners of Waterford Wines.

Note to editor :

Article 8(1)(b) of the EU of the community trade mark regulations provides that, where the proposed mark is identical or similar to another's earlier mark and is sought to be registered in connection with the same or similar goods as the earlier mark, its registration will be refused if such identity or similarity is likely to give rise to confusion in the market place. Confusion in this context includes the likelihood of any association of the proposed mark with the earlier mark.

Issued by : FD Beachhead

Family Law

Mother denied all access to her children - 10 May
A court has denied the former wife of a rich City financier all access to their three children after she was found to be turning them against him. In an extraordinary ruling, the woman, who was also judged to be too indulgent a parent, has been legally barred from seeing her children for three years. She was jailed for approaching one of them in the street and telling him she loved him in breach of a court order. She is facing a possible return to jail this summer for posting a video about her plight on the internet. The woman judge presiding over the case justified banning contact between the mother and her children because they were being placed in "an intolerable situation of conflict of loyalties resulting in them suffering serious emotional harm". -
Times Online website

City tycoon in £11 million divorce battle admits to keeping a second family - 12 May
City tycoon Brian Myerson, who is fighting an £11 million divorce settlement on grounds that the recession slashed his wealth, has admitted to leading a double life with a mistress and child for seven years. Mr Myerson, a leading financier, said that he had a secret second family in a house around the corner from his then wife, Ingrid and their three children in Hampstead, north west London. However, he said that he was "an extremely good and caring husband" and in a withering attack, argued that his ex-wife deserves a fraction of the £11.2 million she received. -
Telegraph website

'I would do it all again' - 12 May
Plettenberg Bay polo baron Brian Myerson said he was "an extremely good, caring husband" to his former wife Ingrid - though he enjoyed a 10-year "parallel marriage" to another woman. Myerson, 50, a Johannesburg- born British tycoon, hit the headlines for trying to get a British court to reduce the R142-million divorce settlement awarded to his former wife, Ingrid, on the grounds that the credit crunch had shrunk his fortune. In an interview with the London Evening Standard, the man who often arrived at polo matches in a helicopter said he kept his mistress and love-child secret from his wife but not from his business partners. -
The Times website

Ex-wife asks for more money after former husband's company jumps in value - 14 May
The ex-wife of a businessman has asked a court to increase the size of her divorce payout after his company quadrupled in value. Kim Walkden, 47, accepted a settlement of £482 000 in August 2007, based on an assessment that valued her husband's timber products company at £800 000. But just two months later the firm Triesse was valued at £3.8 million in a takeover deal that netted 47-year-old Martin Walkden £1.75 million. Mrs Walkden, who also receives maintenance of £1 100 a month, took her case to the Court of Appeal after being given permission by a judge to seek a renegotiation of the original settlement. During the hearing her ex-husband's lawyer cited the case of the City financier Brian Myerson, who unsuccessfully attempted to have his £11.2 million divorce payout to his wife cut because his fortune has been wiped out by the recession. -
Telegraph website

Freedom of Religion

Court says no to plea for funeral pyre - 8 May
A Hindu spiritual healer has lost a legal battle for the right to be cremated on a traditional open-air funeral pyre. Devender Ghai, 70, from Newcastle-upon-Tyne, has been campaigning for several years to be allowed a traditional Hindu-style cremation in the United Kingdom. Although permission had been granted by Northumbria Police, the cremation led to outrage as the Department of Constitutional Affairs and Newcastle City Council said it was illegal to hold open-air cremations under the Cremation Act. He was subsequently denied a licence for a pyre site by Newcastle City Council, prompting him to take the case to the High Court in London. -
Sky News website

Law preventing open-air funeral pyres is justified - 18 May
Times Online website

See :
Queen's Bench Division
8 May 2009
[2009] EWHC 978
Regina (Ghai) v Newcastle upon Tyne City Council

Privacy

Agency denies internet spy plans - 4 May
The UK's electronic intelligence agency has taken the unusual step of issuing a statement to deny it will track all UK internet and online phone use. Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) said it was developing tracking technology but "only acts when it is necessary" and "does not spy at will". The denial follows the home secretary scrapping plans for a single government database for all communications. -
BBC News website

UK 'least wanted' list published - 5 May
The names of some of the people barred from entering the UK for fostering extremism or hatred have been published for the first time. Islamic extremists, white supremacists and a US radio host are among the 16 of 22 excluded in the five months to March to have been named by the Home Office. -
BBC News website

Should people be barred from the UK? - 5 May
The names of the people barred from entering the UK for fostering extremism or hatred have been published for the first time. Do you agree with them being publicly named? -
BBC News website

InfoUpdate : an Information Service supplied by the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society