InfoUpdate
An Information Service supplied by the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society

27 August 2010

This professional service draws attention to current and important items of news
 and members are directed to the hosts' websites

InfoUpdate 19 of 2010
Recent Judgments 

Electronic copies of this information may be obtained from our librarians at help@lawlibrary.co.za or click on the underlined hyperlink where relevant

Western Cape High Court (previously Cape Provincial Division) - http://www.saflii.org.za/za/cases/ZAWCHC/ ; Court rolls at http://www.saflii.org/blog/?page_id=134

Judges halt sand dune mining - 23 August
A Western Cape High Court decision has effectively halted mining operations at two sand dunes in the heart of the Cape Flats. The sand dunes are in the Mitchells Plain suburbs of Westridge and Rocklands. Two judges ruled on Friday that mining operations could not continue until black empowerment mining firm Maccsand had obtained zoning authorisation under the Western Cape Land Use Planning Ordinance (Lupo), as well as environmental clearance under the National Environmental Management Act. - IOL website
Keyphrases :
Environment
Minerals and Energy

High Court finds for municipal planning legislation - 23 August
The Western Cape High Court delivered an important judgment last week confirming that a permit from the national Department of Mineral Resources granted to a local mining company to mine sand on environmentally sensitive municipal land in Mitchells Plain did not give the company the right to ignore land zoning regulations and environmental legislation. In a finding that would affect the mining industry, the court confirmed that national mining legislation did not have veto power over other legislation. The constitution protected municipal planning and the environment. - IOL website

Mining rights legislation to be tightened - 24 August
Western Cape Environmental Affairs MEC Anton Bredell on Tuesday said current legislation on the awarding of mining rights must be tightened to prevent loopholes from emerging. He reacted to a recent High Court ruling which has banned mining company Maccsand from doing work on a piece of land in Rocklands, Mitchell’s Plain. - Eye Witness News website

Environment lobby welcomes landmark ruling - 25 August
When a mining company bulldozed the Rocklands Dune near Mitchells Plain, it set in motion events which led to a landmark court decision: the Department of Mining cannot ride roughshod over environmental and planning laws. Nor are the Department of Mining's laws more powerful than environmental and planning laws, so cannot trump them. - IOL website

See also :
Challenge to mining of sand dunes - 16 April [2010]
Legalbrief website
[InfoUpdate 8 of 2010]

Where's the judgment? : COPE Soweto - 13 August
Preddy Mothopeng appeals to Judge Essa Moosa to deliver ruling. - Politicsweb website

Court says Lekota to stay Cope leader, Shilowa to remain Chief Whip - 19 August
The legal fight as to whether Congress of the People leader Mosiuoa Lekota has the right to lead the party in Parliament was finally resolved yesterday. The Cape High Court ruled in favour of COPE's congress national committee decision to send Mr Lekota to Parliament to be sworn in as an MP and to replace Mvume Dandala as party parliamentary leader. - allAfrica website

I lied to patients, says distraught woman - 25 August
A witness wept as she gave evidence in the Western Cape High Court that she unwittingly lied to ill and injured people who approached her former employers to cure them through stem cell therapy. Danielle Jibrail, worked for Biomark International - a company set up by attorney Stephen van Rooyen and his American wife, Laura Brown. They are wanted in the US to face 51 counts of fraud in connection with the treatment they offered. She was testifying in a damages action brought by Noordhoek paraplegic Justine Asher against ACT, Brown and Van Rooyen after she was told that the treatment was safe and would help her to walk again. Only Brown is defending the action. - IOL website
Keyphrase :
Advanced Cell Therapeutics
Gulf Stream Management Trust
Sean Castle
Sebastian Carlisle

Error sees rapist's life sentence changed - 9 August
A crucial omission in a charge sheet has led to the Western Cape High Court's setting aside the two life sentences imposed on a man convicted of two rapes and substituting them with an effective 17 years' jail. Raymond Dolphin was found guilty of two rapes. However, the charge sheet did not specify that the State would rely on Minimum Sentence legislation in prosecuting Dolphin. - IOL website

Fraud accused win plea for investors - 17 August
The Western Cape High Court has ordered the police and two banks to unfreeze the bank accounts of two businesses linked to a Khayelitsha man accused of operating a fraudulent investment scheme in his neighbourhood. The man, Mzwandile Pato, and his wife, Nosisa, have been charged with fraud worth R5-million and appeared in the Khayelitsha Magistrate's Court in July, where each was granted bail of R15 000. The two businesses are close corporations Mthuthulezi Funeral Services and Fola Investments. - allAfrica website

Teacher sues education MEC for R400 000 - 18 August
A 40-year-old teacher is suing the Western Cape Education MEC for R400 000 in damages in the Western Cape High Court, saying that the education department provided police with false information when instituting a fraud investigation against her. The MEC denied the allegations in responding papers. The department claims that Sizeka Mbebe fraudulently filled in a form which effectively changed the banking details of the school, Umyezo Wama Apile Combined School in Grabouw, to that of her personal bank account. However, Mbebe says that she was handed the form so that she could supply her personal banking details to the department for salary purposes. - IOL website

Dina : I caused so much hurt - 17 August
Dina Rodrigues has finally broken her silence about her role in the murder of six-month-old baby Jordan-Leigh Norton and has "accepted responsibility" for her actions. "I have accepted responsibility for what I have done and the families I've hurt. I put them through hell and I must live with it", Rodrigues told an audience at Pollsmoor Prison on Monday that included Correctional Services Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula.Rodrigues must still serve another 22 years before she becomes eligible for parole but yesterday she pleaded with Mapisa-Nqakula for "another chance". - IOL website

See also : Reopening Hlophe case not in public interest, says JSC [South Africa]

InfoUpdate : an Information Service supplied by the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society