InfoUpdate
An Information Service supplied by the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society

16 October 2009

This professional service draws attention to current and important items of news
 and members are directed to the hosts' websites

InfoUpdate 22 of 2009
Useful Links
and Items of Interest 

Electronic copies of this information may be obtained from our librarians at help@lawlibrary.co.za or click on the underlined hyperlink where relevant

United States

Courts

Supreme court term has major gun rights, business cases - 5 October
The US Supreme Court will again consider gun rights and decide an important case that could loosen restrictions on corporation spending in political campaigns in its new term beginning on Monday. - Reuters website

In precedential ruling, Second Circuit sets high standard for alien tort plaintiffs in Sudanese human rights case - 5 October
Plaintiffs suing global corporations for their alleged role in human rights abuses abroad may want to consider avoiding the Second Circuit after the appellate court's 68-page decision last Friday. It not only affirmed the dismissal of a case against a Canadian energy company, it set a high bar for future Alien Torts Statute plaintiffs. The plaintiffs in the Sudanese case alleged that Talisman Energy aided and abetted human rights abuses by the government in Khartoum. But Manhattan federal district court judge Denise Cote granted Talisman's motion for summary judgment, finding that the plaintiffs had not shown that Talisman provided substantial assistance to the government for the purpose of committing crimes. In affirming Judge Cote's ruling, the Second Circuit articulated a high standard for proving the requisite state of mind of a defendant. The plaintiffs in the case had argued that the standard should be mere knowledge of the human rights abuses. But Talisman, represented by Lovells, urged the court to adopt the international law standard that requires plaintiffs to show that defendants intended to further the crimes. - The Am Law Litigation Daily website
Keyphrase :
United States. 'Apartheid Case'

See :
Court decision

Criminal Justice System

Execution troubles - 6 October
On the afternoon of Tuesday, September 15, Romell Broom sat in his Ohio prison cell hoping for a last-minute court reprieve that never came. But in the hours that followed, the 53-year-old faced a grisly ordeal that would make him the first US prisoner in more than six decades able to tell the story of his execution. - News24 website
[Firsthand account]

Judge accused of sex with inmates - 5 October
The trial of a former US judge accused of having sex with male inmates in exchange for leniency is set to start in Mobile, Alabama. Herman Thomas denies the charges, which include sodomy, kidnapping, extortion, sex abuse and assault. Up to 15 current and former prisoners are set to testify against him at the jury trial. - BBC News website

Cyberlaw

Ringtones are not public concerts - 16 October
The American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP) sued AT&T and Verizon looking to recoup additional royalty fees from people who use ringtones. ASCAP members already receive money from ringtone purchases, but they wanted more money. You know, like a little charge every time a phone rings or something. They lost. - Above the Law blog

See : Judgment

Finance

Trustee sues Madoffs who helped run firm - 3 October
Four Madoffs most closely associated with swindler Bernard Madoff's firm could have stopped the fraud but they milked the business to buy everything from luxury vacation homes to paying for restaurant meals, a court-appointed trustee said on Friday. The trustee sued the brother, sons and a niece of the imprisoned fraudster for what he said was $198.7 million of misappropriated customer money while they were executives of Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities LLC in New York. - Business Report website

Miscellaneous

The Balloon Boy bust : can authorities come up with federal charges? - 18 October
On Thursday morning, a "homemade flying saucer" took off from the Colorado yard of Richard and Mayumi Heene. The Heenes drew nationwide attention when they claimed that their 6-year-old son Falcon was inside. Now it looks like the Heenes were full of hot air. Robert Thomas, a former assistant to Richard Heene, penned a column for Gawker calling it all a big hoax by his attention-hungry boss, claiming to have discussed a plan like this with Heene earlier this year. The authorities appear to agree and announced last night that they will be filing charges. - Above the Law blog

The Balloon Boy Show comes to a court near you - 19 October
Whether it's true that this was a hoax has yet to be proven, but if so, it begs the question: Was it wrong?  Was it a crime? Should the Heenes be prosecuted for causing a nation to care about the welfare of their son? The answer, unfortunately, is that this was not only wrong, and likely unlawful, but also a terribly bad precedent that has to be squelched quickly. - Simple Justice blog

Why we watched Balloon Boy - 16 October
Thursday, as we all watched the televised spectacle of what everyone believed was a 6-year-old boy trapped in a wooden box attached to a helium balloon that was soaring uncontrollably thousands of feet above the earth, it seemed that our deepest fears were being turned into myth before our very eyes.  After it was discovered that the boy, Falcon Heene, was hiding in his attic the whole time and that the Heene family had courted public attention several times by appearing on a reality-TV show—and after the child blurted out to a TV interviewer that his parents had told him to hide "for the show"—something even stranger than the original story started to happen. The terrifying thought of a helpless boy trapped in a vagrant balloon thousands of feet above the earth gave way to another, equally startling, notion. Perhaps American truth and American falsehood had blurred so completely that we were all, literally, up in the air when it came to knowing what the hell was going on around us. And if this was what was happening, if the whole country was, in effect, soaring uncontrollably through the sky, over forbidding valleys and hills, to where wilder things than we could ever imagine are, who was going to help us now? - Lee Siegel on The Daily Beast blog

InfoUpdate : an Information Service supplied by the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society